Specialty Pizza
Homestyle pizzas with unique sauce blend and perfectly crisp crusts.
- 12-cut homestyle option available
- Distinctive spicy sauce recipe
- Crisp, airy crust texture
At a Glance
Johnny's Pizza Shop stands out in Ellwood City for their unique menu offerings including signature deep-fried puffs and expertly crafted meatball sandwiches alongside traditional pizzas. Customers consistently praise the exceptional customer service and staff dedication, while the homestyle pizzas feature distinctive sauce and perfectly crisp crusts that keep locals coming back.
- Exceptional customer service
- Unique menu specialties
- Perfectly crafted sandwiches
- Fresh, quality ingredients
Why Customers Choose Johnny's Pizza Shop
Based on 198 customer reviews
- Signature deep-fried puffs found nowhere else locally
- Meatball sandwiches crafted with artistic presentation
- Homestyle pizza with distinctive spicy sauce and crisp crust
- Staff who genuinely care about getting orders right
- Fish dinners prepared by experienced guest chefs
- Beautiful food packaging that shows attention to detail
Location & Local Context
Address: 609 4th St, Ellwood City, PA 16117, USA
Phone: (724) 752-7754
Hours: Friday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Monday Closed, Sunday Closed, Tuesday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Thursday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Wednesday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Parking: Free street parking available on Beaver Avenue
Peak times: Friday evenings 5-8pm and weekend afternoons
Nearby neighborhoods: Ellwood City, New Castle, Beaver Falls
Nearby landmarks: Near Ellwood City Area Historical Society, Close to Ewing Park, Walking distance from downtown Ellwood City
Services & Offerings
Deep-Fried Puffs
Johnny's famous signature appetizer that customers rave about.
- Loaded with pepperoni
- Perfectly crispy exterior
- Best experienced fresh
Gourmet Sandwiches
Beautifully crafted sandwiches, especially the popular meatball sandwich.
- Artistically presented
- Carefully packaged
- Perfect flavor balance
Fish Dinners
Special fish dinners featuring two pieces of fried fish with sides.
- Includes mac and cheese and coleslaw
- Prepared by guest chef Chris
- Available on select days
Customer Reviews
⭐ 4.3 out of 5
198 total reviews
Most Frequently Mentioned
- Customer Service (89 mentions)
- Food Quality (76 mentions)
- Meatball Sandwiches (45 mentions)
- Deep-Fried Puffs (38 mentions)
Rating trending upward with improved order accuracy. 15 new reviews this month.
★★★★★
“Definitely recommend going here if you're looking to a pizza night! The food is...I have no words, it is just spectacular! Amazing customer service, staff is always super friendly and works butt off in there! I definitely am going here more often in the future! I am so lucky to have found my new go-to spot in Ellwood!”
— Logan Shafer★★★★★
“Best deep fried puffs ever!! Great customer service. UPDATE: These absolutely do not taste or feel like they did the day of car cruise. Highly disappointed in my visit today 10/17/23. They were soggy and smaller and nowhere near the amount of pepperoni inside. I was looking forward to these for so long. I will never buy outside the car cruise again. Update: Turns out all I had to do was say something and she absolutely fixed my order and remade it for me. I guess the lesson is just say something 🤷”
— leah schlack★★★★★
“Johnnys Pizza is absolutely fabulous!! I order their meatball sandwich all of the time and it’s always perfect. Not only does it taste amazing, but it’s crafted together perfectly and is so beautiful to look at. It’s always packaged with care!! We love Johnnys!”
— Kait Haynes Photography LLC★★★★★
“We got the fish dinners. It came with 2 pieces of fried fish, mac and cheese, and coleslaw. It was all so good! It was $18 and worth every penny! Chris from the Wolverine was cooking fish at Johnny's. We'll definitely get it again”
— Jennifer WhiteFrequently Asked Questions
Johnny's signature appetizer - crispy fried dough pockets loaded with pepperoni that customers absolutely love.
We have online ordering available with pickup, though there's a $1.50 convenience fee for online orders.
Our homestyle pizzas feature a unique spicy sauce and perfectly crisp, airy crust that sets us apart from typical pizza shops.
Fish dinners are prepared by our guest chef Chris on select days - call ahead to check availability.
Our famous meatball sandwich comes perfectly crafted with our signature sauce and is beautifully packaged for takeout.
Business Activity
Status: Open now
Peak hours: Friday 5-8pm
Special events: Car cruise appearances
Popular this week: Meatball subs, Deep-fried puffs
Similar Businesses Nearby
Shakespeare's Restaurant & Pub
⭐ 4.6 (1237) · 1.8 miles
1495 Mercer Road, Ellwood City
Pizza Joe's
⭐ 4.5 (307) · 0.4 miles
128 Spring Avenue, Ellwood City
Subway
⭐ 3.9 (128) · 1.4 miles
265 Pennsylvania 288 Rm #1316, Ellwood City
National Grind Coffee & Tea Shop
⭐ 4.8 (338) · 0.2 miles
425 Lawrence Avenue, Ellwood City
Breaking Bread Co.
⭐ 4.7 (598) · 0.3 miles
530 Lawrence Avenue, Ellwood City
Vinny's Pizza And Restaurant
⭐ 4.5 (630) · 0.4 miles
620 Beaver Avenue, Ellwood City
People Also Search For
- Pizza Ellwood City PA
- Italian restaurant Lawrence County
- Deep fried puffs Pennsylvania
- Meatball sandwiches near me
0/100
Online Visibility Score: Excellent
How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.
Reviews & Reputation29/35
Online Presence33/33
Business Completeness17/17
Engagement5/15
This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.
Powered by Buzza AI on Clover
Johnny's Pizza Shop manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.